top of page

Patient Online Review Statistics

Nov 10
7 min read

Signal Hill Strategies gathered patient review data from 11 published sources, including nine patient and consumer surveys published from 2014 to 2025, a JAMA study of 600 physicians on 28 rating sites, and Reputation's analysis of more than 1 million patient reviews. As of Q4 2026, the data shows most patients check reviews first and expect at least 4 stars.

Key Findings

  • A median of 81.5% of US patients read or consider online reviews before choosing a provider, across four surveys published from 2023 to 2025.

  • 53% of patients would not consider a provider rated below 4 stars in Tebra's June 2025 survey of 3,964 US adults.

  • 77.78% of respondents used or would use Google to check healthcare reviews in RepuGen's 2025 survey, compared with 26.79% for Healthgrades.

  • 34% of physicians sampled in Boston, Portland, and Dallas had no review on any rating site in a 2017 JAMA study.

  • Positive Yelp reviews of US healthcare facilities fell from 54.3% before March 2020 to 47.9% afterward, through 2023.

When researchers surveyed 2,137 US adults for JAMA in September 2012, 19% called physician rating sites very important, and only 5% said they or a family member had ever rated a doctor. Since then, patient surveys have stopped asking whether people look at ratings and started asking how many stars it takes to win their visit.

Our analysts lined up the most recent patient surveys on review use, star-rating thresholds, and review sites, then added peer-reviewed studies and a large review analysis to show what patients find once they look. We kept each survey's own question wording, since the questions differ, and calculated medians and combined shares from the published figures.

In the following sections, we compare how many patients read reviews, the star ratings they will accept, the review sites they use, and the average ratings physicians and hospitals receive.

How Many Patients Read Online Reviews Before Choosing a Doctor

Each survey words its question a little differently, from reading reviews to ranking them as the top factor in a decision. Lined up side by side, they point the same way.

Patient Use of Online Reviews by Survey (2014 to 2025)

Survey

Published

What Was Measured

Share

JAMA research letter

2014

Called physician ratings very or somewhat important

59%

Software Advice

2020

Use online reviews to evaluate physicians

90%

Reputation

2023

Read online patient reviews

86%

Yext

2024

Say patient reviews are the top factor in choosing a provider

74%

rater8

2025

Check reviews before choosing a new provider

84%

Tebra

2025

Read reviews before choosing a provider

79%

RepuGen

2025

Consider reviews when choosing a provider

73.28%

Bar chart of the share of US patients who read or consider online reviews in four surveys from 2023 to 2025, with a median line

Key Findings

  • Reviews now shape choices, not only first impressions. In rater8's December 2024 survey, 61% of patients said they put online reviews ahead of referrals from friends and family, and 40% had canceled an appointment or changed a care plan based on reviews alone.

  • Reviews already swayed decisions a decade ago. Among adults who looked up physician ratings in 2012, 35% chose a doctor because of good ratings and 37% avoided one because of bad ratings. In Reputation's 2023 survey, 65% said ratings led them to pick one provider or location over another.

  • Ratings can compete with insurance networks. Software Advice found in 2020 that 43% of patients would go outside their network for a provider with better reviews, and newer surveys will show whether that share holds as more people check ratings first.

Minimum Star Rating Patients Accept: The 4-Star Threshold

Star ratings work as a quick filter before anyone reads a written review. Several surveys asked patients where they draw that line.

Share of Patients Who Hold Providers to 4 Stars (2022 to 2025)

Survey

Published

Threshold Question

Share

Press Ganey

2025

Would reconsider a referral if a provider is rated below 4 stars

84%

RepuGen

2025

Name 4, 4.5, or 5 stars as their minimum acceptable rating

77.92%

Reputation

2023

Need at least 4 stars to engage with a provider

73%

Tebra

2025

Won't consider a provider with fewer than 4 stars

53%

Press Ganey, boomers

2022

Say 4 stars is the lowest rating they would accept

46%

Press Ganey, millennials and Gen Z

2022

Say 4 stars is the lowest rating they would accept

29%

Bar chart of the share of US patients who hold providers to a 4-star minimum in four surveys, from 84% to 53%

Key Findings

  • Some patients set the bar higher than 4 stars. In RepuGen's 2025 survey, 22.56% named 4.5 stars as their minimum and 8.26% would only accept 5 stars.

  • Older patients were more likely to name exactly 4 stars as their floor. In a Press Ganey survey published in February 2022, boomers were 17 points more likely than millennials and Gen Z to call 4 stars the lowest rating they would accept.

  • Volume and recency count too. Just over half of rater8's respondents (51%) read at least 6 reviews before booking, and 40.02% of RepuGen respondents treat reviews 1 to 2 years old as outdated, so a high rating built on a few old reviews carries less weight.

Which Review Sites Patients Use for Doctors and Hospitals

Patients know more review sites than they turn to. RepuGen's 2025 survey asked about both, which shows where awareness becomes use.

Healthcare Review Site Awareness and Use (2025)

Review Site

Aware of the Site

Use or Would Use

Google

84.03%

77.78%

WebMD

66.96%

52.47%

Yelp

59.16%

29.75%

Facebook

51.98%

25.56%

Healthgrades

31.19%

26.79%

Zocdoc

22.03%

13.46%

RateMDs

21.29%

13.58%

Doctor.com

14.98%

13.46%

Vitals

9.90%

7.41%

Grouped bar chart of awareness and use of nine healthcare review sites, led by Google and WebMD

Key Findings

  • Google keeps most of its audience. Its drop from awareness to use is 6.25 points, compared with 29.41 points for Yelp and 26.42 points for Facebook, so many patients know those two sites without using them for healthcare.

  • Healthcare-only sites have smaller but steadier audiences. Healthgrades, Doctor.com, and Vitals each lose fewer than 5 points between awareness and use.

  • WebMD is the clear second choice for patients checking reviews, ahead of healthcare-only sites such as Zocdoc, RateMDs, and Vitals. For practices, Google and WebMD profiles reach most of these respondents, and the next RepuGen survey will show whether healthcare-only sites gain ground.

Average Online Ratings for Physicians vs Hospitals

Surveys show what patients look for. Review data shows what they find, and the picture differs between individual doctors and hospitals.

Online Rating Benchmarks for Physicians and Hospitals (2021 to 2023)

Measure

Earlier Value

Later Value

Average physician star rating

4.54 (2021)

4.6 (2022)

Average hospital star rating

3.57 (2021)

3.7 (2022)

Physician review volume

2021 base

Up 53% (2022)

Yelp facility reviews rated 4 or 5 stars

54.3% (before March 2020)

47.9% (March 2020 to 2023)

Bar chart of average online star ratings for physicians and hospitals in 2021 and 2022, with physicians near 4.6 and hospitals near 3.7

Key Findings

  • Physicians outscored hospitals by 0.9 stars in 2022, and both gained from 2021. Hospital ratings rose 0.13 stars, about twice the physician gain of 0.06, and Reputation's next healthcare report will show whether hospitals keep closing the gap.

  • Many doctors have few reviews to judge. Among physicians in a 2017 JAMA sample who had any reviews, the median was 7 reviews across all sites, a small base for a star average.

  • Most patients do not post reviews on their own. 57% of rater8 respondents rarely or never leave one, but 74% are at least somewhat likely to when their provider asks, and Reputation found more people reviewed after a positive experience (39%) than a negative one (24%).

For patients, reading reviews has become a standard step in choosing care, and most expect at least 4 stars before they book. For practices, that puts star ratings and review counts in the same place as insurance and location when a new patient compares options.

Doctors generally clear that bar, while hospitals average below it, and facility reviews on Yelp turned more negative after the pandemic began.

The broader trend is more reviews, read more closely, on a small number of sites led by Google.

So if you are choosing a provider, these surveys suggest looking past the star average to how many reviews there are and how recent they are.

  • We compiled figures from patient surveys, peer-reviewed studies, and an industry review analysis published from 2014 to 2025, and opened each source on November 10, 2026.

  • Survey sizes where published: JAMA 2,137 adults (September 2012); Yext 1,051 adults who looked online for a provider (June 27 to July 10, 2024, weighted); rater8 1,008 adults (December 2024); Tebra 3,964 adults (June 29, 2025); RepuGen 1,212 respondents (2025). Software Advice reports 854 patients surveyed, of whom 498 had relevant experience.

  • Question wording differs across surveys, so shares are shown as each source published them, with the measure named in each table row.

  • The 81.5% figure is the median of four surveys from 2023 to 2025 that measured reading, checking, or considering reviews: Reputation, rater8, Tebra, and RepuGen.

  • The RepuGen 4-star share adds respondents who chose 4, 4.5, or 5 stars as their minimum acceptable rating.

  • Average ratings come from Reputation's analysis of over 1 million patient reviews across 200,000 physicians and hospitals. Yelp figures cover reviews of US healthcare facilities from 2014 to 2023.

  • Derived figures, including medians, combined shares, point gaps, and rating changes, were calculated from these data.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page